On Pie: Baked and Dreamt of

I may not have le cordon blue or any ribbon at all proclaiming me master pie maker but I am determined to raise my children on pie, with pie and knowing pie.

My childhood was satisfactory, thank you very much. Even without pie as we know it.

All that pielessness is being addressed, corrected. 

Mini-apple pies

I’ll have you know that I’ve baked more sweet pies in the last 6 months than I have in the entire preceding decades, thanks to 3 great women – Antonia James, a food52er who introduced me to ‘Humble Pie’ and its author Anne Dimock, who motivated me to seek more and find I did,  and the book of ‘Pie’ by Angela Boggiano.

And this is what I’m referring to when I talk pie – sweet, dessert pies, of fruit, and booze and berries. 


Good things sure do come in threes. 3 children, 3 visits to New York City. 3 women and pie.

See, pies have always been my Everest. Too hard to climb on a whim. To scary, too risky – much too difficult for the judge and jury would hold no mercy. Strange from someone who’s conquered recipes, 17 pages long.

But dare suggest she make simple pie crust….. then watch her run away.

Yet I do the checks.

Food processor? Check

Butter, flour, sugar, salt? Check

Ability to rustle up pie filling? Check

Till I met Miss Anne of Humble Pie, who so enthralls me with her childhood tales of pie making. From apple picking, to rotten apple disposal and the perfect flour-fat ratio for crusts.

She makes pies doable. And to ensure my accountability, I read portions of her book to my children. To prepare them for their pie-eating future.

For I want my children to have pie.

Why? There’s a world of learning and travel that can be packed into a crust. A certain sophistication, confidence and elegance in those who are conversant with crust. Flaky, buttery, sweet. Those who have the courage and boldness to ask ‘Can I have another slice of pie?’, dessert fork in hand. Who can conquer he who seeks more? Pie? And is able to ask for it?

Not I.

And this is where I salute Miss Dimock for she goes the route I like – she talks about pies in the freezer. Of which I currently have 1. That’s a number that’s far better than none. Its a cheese crust pastry, stuffed with apple-calvados filling. Set in a pie mould and well-wrapped.

Deep-frozen Apple Pie

That’s only one pie I’ve shared with you.

The son and I craft the most gorgeous mini apple pies, stuffed with a filling like in the one-frozen-pie version but petit, reminiscent of Christmas mince pies.

The daughters favour apple tarts and berry ones too.

But it’s the spiced rhubarb crumbles that currently have the medal. From Edinburgh to Port Harcourt, these bakes have become legendary.

Tea-poached Apple & Rhubarb Crumble – Bubbling away!

Each one devoured (well, save for the cherry for which I used pie filling, which was too runny, which ended up trashed.)

B, my pie’ner in pie (pie makers in arms) has been exploring various version of the bake. So much so that her husband, a foodlover…though not wont to have conversations about food accosts us both one day, on our return home for work – we carpool.

He is perplexed as to the varied names pies and tarts bear. He bemoans the complexity of describing them when simpler terms and phrases exist.

In a week he’s heard pie, tart and crumble. And he doesn’t know which is what. Our explanations confuse him on day 1 but by day 3, he gets it. As we drive home from work, he shares his proposal to the pie world and frankly it makes some sense:


Why not call a pie a pie, that has a top and bottom crust.

And why not say of a tart ‘it is a pie without a top crust’ and of a crumble, ‘It is a pie without a bottom crust!

We smile, B and I. He’s come a long way…. and probably would LOVE ‘Its Not Easy Eating Green’s’ ‘A Simple Dictionary of Fruit Desserts’. Which I too LOVE! For there, she shares all the details which show up the desserts for what they are.

I don’t scare him into eternal submission by bringing up the subject of buckles and grunts, of slumps and ….. and definitely not of pandowdy. You didn’t hear me mention swamp pie or slab pie and cobblers, or Bettys.

On my part, I need to make up for pies not baked! And I have.

Delicious tea-poached apple-rhubarb crumble

I took a gorgeous recipe from food52, and topped it with an oatmeal and flour crumble. Multiple times. Winner every time.

Then I attempted the ‘classic’ combination of strawberry and rhubarb. And Tiger & Strawberries recipe is a godsend. It may not look pretty….but it was oh so good!

Strawberry & Rhubarb pie, with a crumble topping

So yes, I’m living the life, living a life of pie and loving it too.

The pie recipe I share with you is adapted from ‘Pie’, by Angela Boggiano.

But first a short story on hope, loss and restoration. And a bottle of Calvados.

Charles De Gaulle airport, May 2013

The cheapest bottle of Calvados was all I could afford. I liked the sound of the name anyways ‘Pere Magloire’. I liked it much better than the 500 euro bottles behind the glass doors.


And it set me back a mere 20 euros plus.

I held it gingerly all the way from the duty-free shop to the airplane. I thought about my apple pies as we flew over the ocean, seated in ‘cattle class’.

And when we arrived Port Harcourt at 8 pm that night, I still had it in hand while we waited for the runway shuttle to take us to the Arrivals hall. I was tired and set my bag, with the Calvados on my suitcase. It was unstable. I was well aware but still….I was tired, and had managed a few thousand miles with no ill happening.

I set my bag on the suitcase. It fell and it broke.

I watched the runway soak up my apple brandy, drink of it greedily and I could not scream or shout. For I had done it to myself.

All that remained of my drink, of my almost 30 euros was shards of glass, white netting and a plastic duty-free bag.

Just as I stood, in shock, wondering whether to cry, or to look for a way to save what was left….my phone rang. It was my sisters – older and younger.

I shared my tragedy. They were in London, passing by Paris the following day.

Yes, they offered to get me a new bottle and guess what? They did. And we lived happily together forever.

In a life where I’ve made it up to them, with pie.


Mini Apple Calvados Pies, adapted from ‘Pie’ by Angela Boggiano

My adjustments:

Makes 12 pies

For the Pastry
200g plain/all-purpose flour
50 g unsalted butter, in cubes
50 g lard or white vegetable fat
2 tablespoons caster sugar
Pinch of salt
3 – 6 tablespoons of ice cold water
For the Filling
25 g unsalted butter, in cubes
6 – 8 tart apples, peeled, cored and cut into chunks
100g caster sugar (increased from the recipe’s 75g)
1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon (increased from the recipe’s 1/4 teaspoon)
Grated zest from 1/2 lemon
3 tablespoons of Calvados or Brandy
4 tablespoons of double cream (in my case whipping cream)
Make the Pastry

In a food processor, combine the flour, butter, lard, sugar and salt. Pulse for 30 – 40 seconds till the butter is broken up. The texture will be uneven, with small and large bits. This will change once the water is added.

Add the water, by the tablespoon, starting with 3 and run the food processor for about 10 – 20 seconds. You may need to add more water – I typically end up using 6 tablespoons of water to get the texture I like.

The ‘dough’ is ready – not when it forms a ball but when the mixture is like bread crumbs, usually about 40 – 60 seconds of running the processor.

Turn the mixture out onto some clingfilm/plastic wrap and then shape into a disc.

Don’t worry if the dough doesn’t look ‘evenly textured: the bits of butter and flour bake up to create a nice, crisp-crumbly crust.

Allow the wrapped dough to rest in the fridge for at least 15 minutes, and up to 2 days.

The pastry also freezes well.

Make the Filling

Melt the butter and add the sugar, cinnamon, and lemon zest. Allow to cook until fragrant, a minute or two, stirring all the time.

Add the apples and Calvados, stirring well and let cook on medium to low heat for 10 – 15 minutes until the apples have softened, and some of the liquid is reduced.

Using a stick blender, puree half the mixture and then stir well so the mixture is of coarse texture. Stir in the cream and then set aside to cook completely.

Taste for sugar and spice and adjust to suit your desires.

DSC_0738 DSC_0755

Assemble the pie

Preheat the oven to 190 degrees C/375 degrees F.

On a lightly floured surface, roll out the dough to about 3mm thickness.

Using a cookie cutter – plain or crinkled, cut out 12 discs about 4 inches in diameter, and 12 smaller discs for the covers.

Place the larger discs into the holes of a 12-muffin tray and fill with the cooled apple mixture.

Brush the rim of each mini pie bottom with water and top with the smaller pastry discs.

Pinch the rims together to seal top and base. Then make 3 small slashes on the top of each small pie – to create vent holes.

Bake the pies for 25 – 30 minutes in the centre of the oven, until the edges are golden.

DSC_0758 DSC_0760DSC_0761 DSC_0763

Allow the pies to cool in the tray for 10 – 15 minutes and then remove onto a rack.


Dust with icing sugar and serve warm.


My son was so incredibly proud of his achievements and so were his sisters, his Dad and I!

And thus began our pie journey.

A journey that has seen me rustle up pies in seconds.

Now it is such that I can get home from work, and in that hard hour – the one sandwiched between the rapidly setting sun and homework-dinner-bedtime….I can get home and still rustle up a pie. Or tart.

Like this one. A cheddar cheese crust layered with Meyer Lemon caramel, topped with pastry cream, leftover from a weekend’s Boston Cream Pie and topped with slices of pink, fragrant apple slices, crisp to eat and juicy to bake.


Its even possible that while dinner is being eaten, this beauty is busy baking……

DSC_0855 DSC_0860

Serving us warm pie.


And the Everest is no more. Gone forever, making way for new challenges.

Like chocolate-topped eclairs and croquembouches.

But for now, I’m happy to be a heroine, for myself. And to feed my children pie. So that their stories tomorrow will not be pieless.

What about you? Any Pie stories to share?[wpurp-searchable-recipe]On Pie: Baked and Dreamt of – – – [/wpurp-searchable-recipe]


  1. You’re a really good writer.

    Too bad about the Calvados – that must have been an incredible bummer. But your post was totally engrossing, such a great read. I’m glad I found you – I’ll be back. Thanks.

  2. Sad about the Calvados.

    I grew up in Maine where pie for breakfast was quite common and there was never a week that passed without a couple of pies of fruit or berries. It’s inspiring to see you write about sharing pie with your children as a learning experience.

    • Thanks Maureen – I want them to have the best memories of their parents when they age :-). It might give them added security and confidence in pursuing life…in earnest.

      Sad about the Calvados but grateful my sisters brought me another bottle.

  3. I’m so glad you got a replacement brandy, reading your story, I was like noooo… don’t put the bottle on the suitcase!
    Your pies look delicious, I love the filling – I’m going to try it next time.
    Looking forward to your other pie posts! 🙂

  4. Amen! I’m determined that Little Lucy will grow up on pie too. I loved reading your post…and drooling over your photographs. This is such a lovely recipe, and one that I would like to try soon. Thank you for sharing!

  5. Thank you for leaving a comment at my site…it introduced me to yours! I love your story and I also LOVE pie. Though I was going to be sick if that guy who called himself ‘pie man’ won that Next Food Network Star competition; he made a mockery of pie!

    I had a cake Grandma and pie Grandma. Not that I don’t love some great cakes too but pie and Grandma Bathe were always more near and dear to my heart. I LOVE your rustic pie and can’t deny they’ve become my favorite; I just think the end result is so beautiful.

    • Ha ha – I didn’t watch the pie man on the NFNS……

      I’ll focus on Grandma Bathe. What was your favourite pie?

      And you were blessed though – 2 grandmothers gifted in the bakes. Is that common? You must be in the 5th percentile of offspring with a baking grandma on either side.

      The rustic pies are rather stunning. Such free form, such ease of assembly and no protest – then you get rewarded with gorgeous pie.

  6. Oh these look good!!! And you really had me not breathing when the calvados bottle broke! So glad your sisters stepped up to help! I recently also conquered one of my ‘culinary fears’, the lemon tart 🙂 soon will post!

  7. Oh my goodness – I want one! I love pie with ice cream!!! Bekah featured some mini blueberry pies on our blog but alas I did not get to try them. No you too tempt me with these adorable pastries. *sigh* 🙂

    • I really should try blueberry pies, but I dont have fresh blueberries – I have some that could be reconstituted and I may very well give those a go…..

      Forgive the attempt at temptaion :-).

      Peace, and a small virtual pie?

  8. Ohhh, what lovely sisters to bring you more calvados!!! I would’ve cried. 🙂 Your pies are gorgeous and sound absolutely scrumptious. 🙂

  9. Brown american that i am i have never had pie. Unless sweet potato pie counts, and i turned out alright..relatively speaking

    • Sweet potato pie must count. I haven’t had one ever….though I have tried pumpkin pie twice.

      I’m sure you turned out fine :-). And I did too….but I want to stretch the confines of flour, butter, sugar and eggs. There’s magic in that triad!or quadriad, should I say.

  10. Pie is very much worth the effort! My mom was a pie maker and I learned the basics from her. The fillings are endless from sweet to savory. Each season brings it’s own delightful ideas! Enjoy your adventures in Pie! (My next post will be pie….LOL)

    • Each season does bring its own delights, especially when the previously ‘dreaded’ crust can be rustled up in NO time! Looking forward to your pie stories – which I’ll eagerly devour, I have no doubt.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.