Chocolate Dump-it All Cake a la Hesser


Is not a word I’d use to describe me. Myself. Is that bad English?

I am intrigued by butter. Sticks of butter. The allure of reading American recipes that call for a ‘stick of butter’ hasn’t worn off……and I can count January the 8th as one of my best days in the history of food! Because in a shop round the corner from me, a shop that has given me graham crackers and cheese, gianduja chocolate and Marrons de glace….I found sticks of butter.


Do you hear me? Sticks of butter.

Now if you had sticks of butter on your wish list…just seeing them, hugging and holding them close was a dream come true for me. Do you understand my desire, lust, infatuation? Infatuation….that has seen me buy 10 boxes of 4 quarters. Or 40 sticks.

That is something significant for 40 is a special number, isn’t it?

According to the father of all knowledge encyclopaedic, Wikipedia, Forty is an octagonal number, and as the sum of the first four pentagonal numbers, it is a pentagonal pyramidal number. Adding up some subsets of its divisors (e.g., 1, 4, 5, 10 and 20) gives 40, hence 40 is a semiperfect number.

The point is my 40 sticks of butter bode well. Even if only 16 are left.

 To understand a people, you must live among them for 40 days ~Arabic proverb

A stick, a glorious stick of butter

If I had to describe the butter, pure heaven is what I would say. Rich, creamy, smooth and incredibly tasty….even though it is unsalted! So now, I’ve added American butter to my list of ‘best’  butters that include some of France’s finest and Italy’s too.

Divine butter

And what better way to end the life of a stick of butter than in a cake, (lauded for its easy and spectacular results), than Amanda Hesser’s Chocolate Dump it all cake.

A slab, rich with Minty Marshmallow Frosting

To put things in perspective, since December the 15th 2011, I have made this cake 7 9 times!

On Valentine’s day, my red velvet cakes turned out horrible – soapy…40 cupcakes sat on the counter. Uneaten.

And with promises of cake for my children’s school classes, I reverted to my newly trusted, my never-failing ‘go-to’ recipe…..and ended up with gushing thanks from school mates and teachers alike. They make great cupcakes as well as whole ones.

For Christmas, we had a party – all the neighbours and two cakes graced the table. One sported a minty white chocolate frosting, simply divine and courtesy of Deb/Smitten Kitchen via Jenny/Food52. Stellar topping this is.

Chocolate dump it all cake with white chocolate and mint frosting

And the other, sported a nutty ganache in the guise of Gianduja, hazelnut flavoured chocolate. The same frosting that graced an office table this afternoon when a colleague was leaving! Amidst tears, this cake soothed souls! And bellies.


I have performed all manners of experimentation, deviations and even survived a mistake or two. It appears one can do no wrong to this recipe. Is what I’m trying to say. All hail Judy Hesser.

The mistake? Well, the recipe calls for a cup of water and on one occasion I put in two. Panic ensued but I decided to leave the caskes to bake till they were ready. They were ‘done’  in the same time and though they didn’t have the classic chocolate flavour, the cake was delicious and close to the moistness of a red velvet cake. Two cakes still got demolished in record time. Some people (not me, mind you) had it for dinner and breakfast!


I have learnt a lot in the process.


The original recipe calls for caster sugar and I’ve made it with both brown and white, I prefer the brown sugar version by far. It isn’t as ‘sugary’ as the white version and has more depth of caramel and toffee tones, not to mention being ‘smooth’.

This is about the only time I think dark chocolate really works in a recipe! My milk chocolate version was more ‘cocoa cake’, than deep, rich chocolate. (The darkest chocolate I’ve used is 85% cocoa solids and it turned out luscious!)

I’ve used champagne vinegar instead of cider vinegar, and it worked very well though I got a better rise with the cider vinegar

I’ve baked the cake in all manners of pans – as cup cakes, in regular round 9 inch pans, in springforms, and most exciting, in a giant cupcake pan!


Chocolate Dump-It Cake, Adapted from Judith Hesser via Amanda Hesser

Makes 2 cakes

Changes to the recipe highlighted in green

2 cups dark brown sugar
4 ounces (± 110g) unsweetened chocolate
2 tablespoons (Hershey’s) cocoa powder, and extra to dust the pan
1/ 4 pound unsalted butter (1 stick), plus more for greasing the pan
1 cup water
2 cups all-purpose flour, plus more for dusting the pan if you’d rather not use cocoa
2 teaspoons baking soda
1 teaspoon baking powder
1 teaspoon sea salt 
1 cup milk
1 teaspoon cider vinegar
2 eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Pre-heat the oven to 180 degrees C or (375 degrees F), and place a baking sheet on the lowest rack, to catch any drips when the cake bakes. Put the sugar, unsweetened chocolate, cocoa powder, butter and 1 cup of water in a saucepan. Place over medium heat and stir occasionally until all of the ingredients are melted and blended. Remove from the heat and let cool slightly.

Meanwhile, sieve together the flour, baking soda, baking powder and salt. In a small bowl, stir together the milk and vinegar.

Grease and flour a 9-inch tube pan or two smaller pans (which I personally prefer). I tend to grease the pans, line them with parchment and then grease and dust with cocoa powder. This is not necessary, but parchment does make getting the cake out easier.


When the chocolate in the pan has cooled a bit, whisk in the milk mixture and eggs. In several additions and without overmixing, whisk in the dry ingredients. When the mixture is smooth, add the vanilla extract and whisk once or twice, to blend. Pour the batter into the tube pan(s) and bake on the middle rack until a skewer inserted in the center comes out clean, about 30 to 35 minutes.Let the cake cool for 10 minutes, then remove from the pan and cool on a rack. (This can be tricky – if someone is around, enlist them to help. Place a ring of wax paper on top of the cake so you have something to grab onto when turning it out.) Let cool completely.


Frost with your topping of choice!!!!


And enjoy.


I promise you – there’ll be no regrets! Have a wonderful weekend! One love.

[wpurp-searchable-recipe]Chocolate Dump-it All Cake a la Hesser – – – [/wpurp-searchable-recipe]


  1. After reading your post I’ll never take sticks of butter for granted again! I, too, am a fan of the marvelous Dump-It Cake and am admiring all your icing variations here. In fact, I haven’t made it in awhile and will do so soon using your changes – love the switch to brown sugar.

  2. Hi Sally-My Custard Pie,

    I am Canadian, but Nigerian by birth, so tell your friend she will enjoy living in Nigeria if she has an open mind; Nigerians are one of the happiest people on earth and we are also very hospitable. She needs an above average income though to be comfortable. She would thrive better in a gated community. Good luck to her 🙂

  3. I struggle with sticks of butter – I just can’t seem to remember what they correspond to weight-wise. We don’t do stick here in Australia so each time I use a US recipe I have to look it up – brain drain!
    Love the giant cupcake – I’ll bet that made you popular!

    • Spot on – it made me popular, and I put a tin which I’ve had for ages to good use. Will probably be making it again today. Aah, yes, if sticks of butter are not available then it could become a ‘chore’….but the results are worth it, I promise!

  4. I do adore your posts! I am so used to buying 4 pounds of butter (16 sticks!) at the infamous big box store that I certainly do take butter for granted! The cake recipe looks delightful, what a lovely dessert to share with others.

  5. I am not a very good baker so it looks like I will have to try this fail proof cake of yours. I always have to have sticks of butter on hand because you just never know when you are going to need it!!! I am liking the texture and brown sugar all the way! Yes!! and Yum!!

    • Many top tips Sally (which I’ve emailed to you as well). Read Oyibos online which is a great resource on Nigeria in general and the larger cities. Its also a good idea to bring some things you can’t live without (that’s true for mose expatriate moves though), and prepare to see a wonderful country, full of contradictions!

  6. Such a joyous and ebulient post! Share your love of butter, but not sticks – I loathe volume measurements and guard my digital scales with my life 🙂 Printing off the recipe now, totally sold (once I’ve converted it to grams 🙂 Thanks Ozoz – favourite recipes are the best.

    • And I love volume measurements, though I wouldn’t try them in Heston Blumenthal type recipes :-). I love the ease with which this comes together, one stick of butter here, one cup of flour there….but I understand! Make it, you’ll have NO regrets. I promise you.

    • Perhaps I should do a post on how to use your giant cupcake – glad I could share something. Just read today that you should fill the base with 3 1/2 cups of batter nad the top with 2 1/2 cups….will give it a go!

  7. No sticks of butter here in Australia. I must weigh the butter and chop it up. Thankfully that’s not so difficult but unwrapping a stick of butter is heaps easier. 🙂

    The cake looks great and I can’t wait to dump soon.

  8. Christian biblicaly speaking it rained 40 days and 40 nights. Ah, only if it would have rained 40 sticks of butter instead, our world might have been filled with Dump-it cake!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.